ACC E28 Carpet review
ACC E28 Carpet review
After some discussion with some of you and looking at the carpet that Roy ordered for the Alpina I decided to be the test mule and order an ACC carpet from Rockauto for the E28.
Good carpets will become hard to find soon, so we need alternatives.
I went ahead and ordered some samples in summer.
There is two different kinds: Cutpile and Essex. Cutpile is a thin material, while Essex is "plush".
Both of them can be had with or without sound insulation backing.
Essex Vs. Cutpile
Samples over factory tan carpet.
After reviewing the samples and some online research I decided to go with the thicker Essex material.
Also, I wanted to go a little darker than the faded factory "anthrazite", so my color of choice was Dark slate.
ACC quoted me $556.20 without the backing and $711.94 with the backing.
Rockauto is $249.79 and $319.79 for the same thing.
Basically the response I got from ACC is that they are not setup for retail sales and can't match the Rockauto price.
I decided to go with the backing, since I found reports online that said the fit would be nicer with.
The carpet comes without any of the cutouts. You will have to copy those over from your old carpet.
The cheap plastic foot bolster will have to go before I install the carpet. I will most likely have the upholstery shop cut a piece in the factory shape and size and sew it in.
Here is some detail pictures:
The sample piece is from a 535 with anthrazite carpet. So if you want to match that you will need the 1097A Charcoal
Next step: Testfitting. I should be able to do that in the next two weeks.
Good carpets will become hard to find soon, so we need alternatives.
I went ahead and ordered some samples in summer.
There is two different kinds: Cutpile and Essex. Cutpile is a thin material, while Essex is "plush".
Both of them can be had with or without sound insulation backing.
Essex Vs. Cutpile
Samples over factory tan carpet.
After reviewing the samples and some online research I decided to go with the thicker Essex material.
Also, I wanted to go a little darker than the faded factory "anthrazite", so my color of choice was Dark slate.
ACC quoted me $556.20 without the backing and $711.94 with the backing.
Rockauto is $249.79 and $319.79 for the same thing.
Basically the response I got from ACC is that they are not setup for retail sales and can't match the Rockauto price.
I decided to go with the backing, since I found reports online that said the fit would be nicer with.
The carpet comes without any of the cutouts. You will have to copy those over from your old carpet.
The cheap plastic foot bolster will have to go before I install the carpet. I will most likely have the upholstery shop cut a piece in the factory shape and size and sew it in.
Here is some detail pictures:
The sample piece is from a 535 with anthrazite carpet. So if you want to match that you will need the 1097A Charcoal
Next step: Testfitting. I should be able to do that in the next two weeks.
Last edited by BenGerman on Oct 22, 2018 6:36 PM, edited 1 time in total.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
In for the updates.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Pretty cool, looking forward to results.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Thanks for doing this Ben.
I'm really, really, looking forward to seeing how it fits!
I'm really, really, looking forward to seeing how it fits!
-
- Posts: 966
- Joined: Oct 26, 2017 3:36 PM
- Location: Fleming Island FL
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Ready for the updates and evaluation- if this goes well, they are about to get slammed with orders!
Thank you for volunteering- I hope you get better than expected results.
Thank you for volunteering- I hope you get better than expected results.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Thanks for taking on this effort!
-
- Posts: 966
- Joined: Oct 26, 2017 3:36 PM
- Location: Fleming Island FL
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Checking in on your research. Very much looking forward to your findings!
-
- Posts: 96
- Joined: Oct 31, 2013 1:43 PM
- Location: SF Bay Area
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Ditto - my car came with no carpet. Hoping there is a decent fitting aftermarket solution out there
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
The carpet is in the car, but I can't make a final statement just yet.
Since it is not precut, I will have to make all the cuts for every hole first, before I can lay it out exactly the way it should be.
Since it is not precut, I will have to make all the cuts for every hole first, before I can lay it out exactly the way it should be.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Hi, lets assume i can get the original molded carpet from bmw for €500,the last production date is 2010.is there any chance that the acc one is a better material because its made with the latest technology ? If price wasn't an issue would one prefer the OE ? The acc look so soft.
My carpet is kaput,the PO smoked a lot so it's full of holes.
I'm waiting for your review and for the clutch spring message that its been shipped.
Thanks.
My carpet is kaput,the PO smoked a lot so it's full of holes.
I'm waiting for your review and for the clutch spring message that its been shipped.
Thanks.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
I would pay that amount in a HEART BEAT for a new, OE carpet set from BMW. If you really think you have a source, please, please share with me. Thanks.Sagi wrote:Hi, lets assume i can get the original molded carpet from bmw for €500,the last production date is 2010.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Hasn't someone asked Ivo already? Because if it is available, I'm with Charlie on this.cek wrote:I would pay that amount in a HEART BEAT for a new, OE carpet set from BMW. If you really think you have a source, please, please share with me. Thanks.Sagi wrote:Hi, lets assume i can get the original molded carpet from bmw for €500,the last production date is 2010.
[I tend to think it is not, all the carpet for all the E28's come up as NLA; Silver Spring and Passport searches come back as "Part Not Found" or "Discontinued"]
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
100%. Don’t get me wrong, the ACC carpet is decent but it needs work to be perfect. I’d be willing to pay money for a new original BMW carpet.cek wrote:I would pay that amount in a HEART BEAT for a new, OE carpet set from BMW. If you really think you have a source, please, please share with me. Thanks.Sagi wrote:Hi, lets assume i can get the original molded carpet from bmw for €500,the last production date is 2010.
-
- Posts: 96
- Joined: Oct 31, 2013 1:43 PM
- Location: SF Bay Area
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Will you be using OE carpet as a template to make your cuts, or marking in car?BenGerman wrote:The carpet is in the car, but I can't make a final statement just yet.
Since it is not precut, I will have to make all the cuts for every hole first, before I can lay it out exactly the way it should be.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
I decided to use the OEM carpet as a template. That’s there reason there hasn’t been a lot of updates recently.
The carpet is back in the basement, it will be a couple of weeks before I’m that far into the car again.
The carpet is back in the basement, it will be a couple of weeks before I’m that far into the car again.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
That was a great info.
-
- Posts: 48
- Joined: Aug 29, 2018 9:18 PM
- Location: 15317
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Hello,
Any update on this? I bought an ACC carpet in June for my project E28 M5 and am about to remove the old carpet. I am only marginally optimistic that the ACC carpet will fit correctly based on the lack of some of the molding. Also, the heel pad on the ACC piece is truly awful compared to the heal and deadpedal pad on my OEM carpet. I would punt, but the OEM carpet has a large threadbare section in the passenger side footwell and I also think it got wet at some point.
One other sticking point. The ACC carpet came as "3 pieces" which included the A-piller kickpanel/speaker covers. The set DID NOT come with any extra carpet for the lower center console or the doors if you have a car with carpet on the door panels. The ACC carpet is a different weave than OEM so it is likely that it won't match. I ended up paying an additional $95 to have a yard of matching roll carpet delivered.
Any update on this? I bought an ACC carpet in June for my project E28 M5 and am about to remove the old carpet. I am only marginally optimistic that the ACC carpet will fit correctly based on the lack of some of the molding. Also, the heel pad on the ACC piece is truly awful compared to the heal and deadpedal pad on my OEM carpet. I would punt, but the OEM carpet has a large threadbare section in the passenger side footwell and I also think it got wet at some point.
One other sticking point. The ACC carpet came as "3 pieces" which included the A-piller kickpanel/speaker covers. The set DID NOT come with any extra carpet for the lower center console or the doors if you have a car with carpet on the door panels. The ACC carpet is a different weave than OEM so it is likely that it won't match. I ended up paying an additional $95 to have a yard of matching roll carpet delivered.
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Pardon my intrusion, but...
Is this not the same carpet? ...and cheaper?
https://www.stockinteriors.com/AutoCarp ... odelId=689
edit: NVM; I compared prices from the ACC website and not RockAuto
Is this not the same carpet? ...and cheaper?
https://www.stockinteriors.com/AutoCarp ... odelId=689
edit: NVM; I compared prices from the ACC website and not RockAuto
-
- Posts: 1316
- Joined: Feb 12, 2006 12:00 PM
- Location: Aiken SC
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Maybe if they are contacted directly, but E28 carpet sets come up as "No Longer Available" on their site.RetiredDoc wrote: Aug 19, 2020 9:42 PM Anyone tried this supplier recently?
https://worlduph.com/bmw/index.htm?gcli ... gLovPD_BwE
-
- Posts: 143
- Joined: Jan 05, 2021 7:32 PM
- Location: Westchester Co NY
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
I’m curious to see if there are any updates to this. Our M5 didn’t come with a carpet. It did come with some padding sets. Are the ACC carpets an acceptable option? Would anyone know what their comparable color is to Natur?
Thx,
Thx,
Re: ACC E28 Carpet review
Just saw this thread. I recently installed an ACC carpet set in my 84 528e. Out of the package it appeared identical to the pics posted above. I went whole hog and installed sound deadener and jute padding before laying the carpet. I found that the molding of the carpet was not very accurate to the shape of the floor plan so I ended up doing a bunch of cutting and patching to get any kind of fit. The good news is that I had enough left over carpet to do my parcel shelf, and when the seats are back in the car and all else is reinstalled the job looks decent. Quality and appearance of the carpet is excellent. To install a hot glue gun was my friend