e28 touring....
e28 touring....
Ok, so I see all these people who want e28 or e30 tourings. Whats keeping us from making our own?? BMW out sourced the original tournings to another company. Seems to me that all you need to do is cut the rear roof off one e28 and graft it onto another e28, put some hinges on the glass and there you go, e28 touring. I might do this when we are about to crush the e28 at the junk yard I work at.
Conception and execution are very different animals. How are you going to extend the roof and drip rails? Plexiglass for windows? Not good on a street car -- looks cheap. How do you expect SUV parts to line up? The enthusiasm is great, but unless you're a master body-panel fabricator, the results are going to be less than stellar.
ok, well you cut off the roof from a e28, then you weld it to the back of another e28... this will extend the drip rails, and the roof. now as for the suv parts, they would be mounting hardware for the oem e28 glass to open up from the rear the car, thats the only suv parts that would be used, mounting hardware for the glass (ie two hinges and a striker/latch for the glass). Making the whole rear open like a real touring would be hard, but making just the glass open would be very easy. I will post pictures in a month when we junk the other e28 of what I mean.Shawn D. wrote:Conception and execution are very different animals. How are you going to extend the roof and drip rails? Plexiglass for windows? Not good on a street car -- looks cheap. How do you expect SUV parts to line up? The enthusiasm is great, but unless you're a master body-panel fabricator, the results are going to be less than stellar.
here is a close up of a tourings rear end
here is both rear ends together now
Do you see what I mean by looking at that last picture?? Im not saying it will be easy but I would rather make my own than bend over and get raped trying to import one.
-
- Posts: 168
- Joined: Mar 21, 2007 3:38 PM
- Location: Minneapolis,MN
open up your narrow mind here, your not just going to slap this crap together, its going to take work to do, blending, welding, and alot of metal work. If a company can do it and still make money then there is a good chance it will work. if people can make e24 convertibles, e30 pickup trucks, e23 limos, why cant a e28 touring be made
My mind isn't narrow -- it's just not open so wide that anything can fall into it! I never said an E28 Touring can't be made. You're twisting my statements into an absurd extreme. I'll believe it when I see it completed and will congratulate you for a job well done if it is indeed well done.Erik J wrote:open up your narrow mind here... why cant a e28 touring be made
-
- Posts: 14507
- Joined: Feb 12, 2006 12:00 PM
- Location: Halfway up the left side of Lake Michigan
- Contact:
I think it's great when someone wants to do (or try) something what others don't. However, I believe the poster is taking the whole project much too lightly.
Probably, together with a lot of strong language, it just ends with 2 less E28's in the world.
Probably, together with a lot of strong language, it just ends with 2 less E28's in the world.
Last edited by Eric_V on Aug 14, 2007 11:58 AM, edited 1 time in total.
turbodan wrote:The e34, e46, e39 and e60 were all production BMW models. I can get parts for those. I cant get parts for an e28 touring.
In addition to that, let's also get this clear as well: E30's were also production tourings as well. BMW didn't outsource any production of any model (specifically chassis) to anyone since Karman did the early E24s and they tried to have Lambo do the M1.Erik J wrote:they just didnt import any of the e28 or e30 ones to the us. e34, e46, e39, and e60 ones are all over the placeC.R. Krieger wrote:If a company had made money, there would be more of them.Erik J wrote:If a company can do it and still make money then there is a good chance it will work.
Any E28 touring was a one-off, privately contracted project.
Yes, there are a few that were made by private coachbuilders, if you will, in Europe. They were not sanctioned or in anyway affiliated with BMW.
And there is a very high probability that you CANNOT get any custom part anymore from any of the builders for an E28 touring.
-Chris
Dont get me wrong though, I think the touring could be a cool car. I wouldn't mind stomping asses around town in a turbo touring. But I dont see it working out. If you've ever had the headliner and insulation out you can see the structure built into the e28 roof. Its more than just sheet metal. You would need to do some serious work to keep the car as rigid as it was with the C pillars where they used to be. Its all tied in.
-
- Posts: 14507
- Joined: Feb 12, 2006 12:00 PM
- Location: Halfway up the left side of Lake Michigan
- Contact:
Picture number 2 is what im talking about, then you need to section in the roof from the other junk car. Yes this is a very extensive project, I said that several times in the first couple posts. not something that I can do in a weekend. I am a ASE certified with welding, auto glass, auto body and for airbags. I am not just some novice trying to make something neat. I personally dont want to destroy my e28 that I drive daily, but I could use the junk yard I work at for test cars. This would be a very very neat car, and to turbo it would make it even cooler.KillerPM wrote:We once made a parade car:
The car went to the yard shortly after that.
because i dont want to get 10 miles to the gallon, that and why would I want to take a e28 that is 3 different colors and has a bent frame and dump 5k on a turbo for it. Minnesota isnt the best place to have a 400hp rear wheel drive car Anywaycrispy wrote:OK, why? Why, why, why, why, why, why? All that time and effort for what? A freakin station wagon? Spend the time and effort (and money) putting a turbo on the car or something... geez man, what are you gonna do next, go round up some kids and go play soccer?
Erik, i salute you - if the cars are otherwise destined for the knackers yard why not give it a go? whats to lose?
I have no idea as to what skills you have but if no one ever tried we still be in the same valley wondering whats over the hill
give it a go and post the results good or bad - i've seen the dutch touring conversions and reckon they rock, sure it won't be easy but it might just work!
I have no idea as to what skills you have but if no one ever tried we still be in the same valley wondering whats over the hill
give it a go and post the results good or bad - i've seen the dutch touring conversions and reckon they rock, sure it won't be easy but it might just work!
Thank you, people who understand that not doing anything is the first step to failing.duncan-uk wrote:Erik, i salute you - if the cars are otherwise destined for the knackers yard why not give it a go? whats to lose?
I have no idea as to what skills you have but if no one ever tried we still be in the same valley wondering whats over the hill
give it a go and post the results good or bad - i've seen the dutch touring conversions and reckon they rock, sure it won't be easy but it might just work!
I also agree. I think that creating an E28 Touring is a great idea and extends a vehicles use and purpose.Erik J wrote: Thank you, people who understand that not doing anything is the first step to failing.
Because you are removing the rear bulk head you will loose a lot of tosional rigidity, so it might start to creak a bit, so I guess you will need to add a fair amount of bracing somewhere on the structure.
I believe that the Dutch tourings used a lot of Mercedes Benz tailgate parts.
Keep us posted.
-
- Posts: 14507
- Joined: Feb 12, 2006 12:00 PM
- Location: Halfway up the left side of Lake Michigan
- Contact:
The bulkhead doesn't have to come out if the rear seat doesn't fold down. That would be a great place to reinforce with a beam - aka 'strut brace'.JohnH wrote:Because you are removing the rear bulk head you will loose a lot of tosional rigidity, so it might start to creak a bit, so I guess you will need to add a fair amount of bracing somewhere on the structure.
Believe me, I know. My next project is either going to restore with turbo and MegaSquirt my 1973 2002, or finally start my scratch design / build mid engine car (see my avatar - CFD work.)Erik J wrote:Thank you, people who understand that not doing anything is the first step to failing.
It's all subjective and I wrote what I wrote with sarcasm and humor, BUT, I am still surprised to see people putting all that time and effort into making a stationwagon. Then again, that kind of work is your specialty and it certainly will be unique which I say go for, so I wish you luck....
Alright, well some of you guys want me to build this thing, so im going to gather the parts, but im not going to spend any money on them. It will be slow going but Ive found a Vixen 21xc ( http://www.vixenrv.com/vixen_history.php ) and would rather have that than a e28 touring. Plans are to gut the vixen and make the inside how I want it to be set up.
-
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Apr 27, 2007 1:37 PM
- Location: Bristol, TN
go for it
Erik,
I have been a wagonphile for years and would love to see it in the works.
To really throw one out there My wish would be a turbo diesel 5speed wagon.
Another minnesota winter and I may be looking for a new rolling chassis for mine.
Where are you located?
I have been a wagonphile for years and would love to see it in the works.
To really throw one out there My wish would be a turbo diesel 5speed wagon.
Another minnesota winter and I may be looking for a new rolling chassis for mine.
Where are you located?
I'm somewhere in the middle guys, I'd love to see it, but doubt it will ever see completion. Don't get me wrong, I want to see it happen, I just think it's more work than you think.
And hows this for an up the ante, how about a 5er trailer. You know, like the guys who cut the cab off a pickup, extend the frame and tongue and make a pickup. I've seen it done with Corvettes and hot rods too, it would be soooooo cool with a BMW. Think about it, the trunk section of an E28 with a tongue on it for towing behind an E28 with a hitch. If only I was better at Photoshop...
And hows this for an up the ante, how about a 5er trailer. You know, like the guys who cut the cab off a pickup, extend the frame and tongue and make a pickup. I've seen it done with Corvettes and hot rods too, it would be soooooo cool with a BMW. Think about it, the trunk section of an E28 with a tongue on it for towing behind an E28 with a hitch. If only I was better at Photoshop...
-
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Mar 25, 2006 3:40 PM
- Location: Chapel Hill, NC
did you read all of the posts? I said a couple of times that THIS WILL BE A HARD PROJECT Read the GOD DAMN POSTS!!!!! Ive already had the idea of a 5er trailer but have no use for that.Mike W. wrote:I'm somewhere in the middle guys, I'd love to see it, but doubt it will ever see completion. Don't get me wrong, I want to see it happen, I just think it's more work than you think.
And hows this for an up the ante, how about a 5er trailer. You know, like the guys who cut the cab off a pickup, extend the frame and tongue and make a pickup. I've seen it done with Corvettes and hot rods too, it would be soooooo cool with a BMW. Think about it, the trunk section of an E28 with a tongue on it for towing behind an E28 with a hitch. If only I was better at Photoshop...
Erik J wrote:did you read all of the posts? I said a couple of times that THIS WILL BE A HARD PROJECT Read the GOD DAMN POSTS!!!!! Ive already had the idea of a 5er trailer but have no use for that.Mike W. wrote:I'm somewhere in the middle guys, I'd love to see it, but doubt it will ever see completion. Don't get me wrong, I want to see it happen, I just think it's more work than you think.
And hows this for an up the ante, how about a 5er trailer. You know, like the guys who cut the cab off a pickup, extend the frame and tongue and make a pickup. I've seen it done with Corvettes and hot rods too, it would be soooooo cool with a BMW. Think about it, the trunk section of an E28 with a tongue on it for towing behind an E28 with a hitch. If only I was better at Photoshop...
Sorry, im a little upset that no one reads the full post before replying to it. You are like the fourth person to say " I just think it's more work than you think. " and this is the third time ive said "i know it will be alot of work"
So please for future reference read the whole post before you reply, then I wont get angry. Sorry if I offended anyone with that last rant.
Because these people are obviously not reading what Im saying otherwise they would not be repeating each other and telling me something that I had stated at the start. I know how much work this will be, ive done many many projects like this, I work at a junk yard for crying out load what do you think we do when there is nothing going on? We build stupid crap out of other stupid crap. If you have something NEW to say then I will answer it, but if your going to be a retard and repeat the same thing then you will not get a response from me.Eric_V wrote:Erik J,
With all due respect, but how are you going to push through with this project if you jump up like a herd of fleas, just because four people made the same comment?
No offence....
Also, for all of you who dont think that I cant build this... what are you basing your assumption on?? is the fact that you have never met me? that you dont know what my background is in car building?? or is the fact that you think no one is as good as you are so there is no way I can do this because you know you cant?? Please enlighten me on how you can tell what I can and cant do based on a few words typed on a internet forum. If only I could be as keen about what others I have never met can do I would not go to certian places I have never heard of because I can sense that they dont know what they are doing....